At first glance, Lipsyte's The Contender is a strange book to mix with Go Ask Alice - see previous post - as one takes place in white suburbia, following a "well-to-do" girl's struggles with drug addiction, while The Contender focuses of a young black male who tries to escape the negative life in the New York ghetto by becoming a professional boxer. To be honest, I too was confused at first, especially when I first began reading the book, as to what one had to do with the other. The narrators couldn't have been more different and the setting - aside from the time period - couldn't have been more different. However, when you read into the books, there is a faint light that suggests that, despite the stark contrast between the narrators, that they are perhaps experiencing something that is very similar, but in a different fashion.
When the reader is first introduced to Alfred Brooks - a notable difference from Go Ask Alice - he is a high school dropout on the fast-track to mediocrity. He has a steady job stocking shelves at a local grocery store, but sees no room for advancement or, the more concerning of the two, a reason to try to advance. His childhood friend James has begun hanging out with a bad crowd that try to coerce Alfred into joining them in their juvenile delinquency. When James is arrested for trying to break into the store that Alfred works at, the bad crowd beats Alfred senseless, sparking a new desire to become something. Alfred goes to to a local gym that trains boxers and signs up. At first, he finds every reason to be bummed out in life and to not train hard, but eventually the training turns his view of the world around. Alfred slips six weeks into his training and spends a night drinking and smoking pot with the bad crowd, and even gets to see James again. James has slipped into a criminal mindset and Alfred hints at his use of cocaine just before passing out from drinking. The next day he is coerced into a day trip with the bad crowd, only to have to flee from the car they took, as it was stolen. He struggles for a few days to recover and almost quits training, but returns and becomes a better fighter than ever. He eventually works his way to amateur fights and has three victories before his trainer tells him it's time to quit. Alfred is adamant about going with the fourth fight, and takes a Rocky style beating that costs him the fight, but gains the respect of those around him, and, most importantly, respect for himself. He then plans to return to school to get his GED, become a part of the Youth Leaders program in his community, and continue helping upcoming fighters at the gym. However, James appears again, for the third and final time, after trying to steal from the same store again. He is badly injured and Alfred manages to coerce into seeking medical attention and coming off "the junk" with his assistance. The novel ends as they walk through the snow en route to a hospital.
Again, this is seemingly heavy material for high school students to read, but it's a terrific moral and the "feel good" story that America loves to hear. To digress momentarily, I do believe I will be coupling this book with John Knowles's A Separate Peace, since they feel almost identical in a sense. However, when comparing this with Go Ask Alice, the critical reader will notice that both narrators live in a world where the have a "good" way of living and a "bad" way of living. In Go Ask Alice, the narrator has the "good" life when she is a square and is not on drugs. She seems to believe that her life is horrible, but it pales in comparison to each bout of her abusing drugs and the aftermath of those choices. Though she eventually swears off the life, it haunts her through her peers and is what ultimately lands her in the mental asylum. Now, Alfred, in The Contender, faces two different worlds as well. The "bad" world is perpetuating the stereotypical lifestyle of the ghetto resident that James and the bad crowd demonstrate. These kids steal, drink, smoke, and go to jail, while the boxers - the "good" way of life - seek to better themselves physically and advise Alfred on how to better himself with education and hard work. Unlike the unnamed narrator from Go Ask Alice, Alfred brings his baggage to the beginning of the story and is able to overcome it without the suggestion of his untimely demise shortly after the text. However, the critical reader will notice that the two struggle between these two ways of life and slip in and out of both of them, eventually choosing to live the "good" life, despite what is going on around them. This will be an interesting discussion to have with the students after they have read both novels.































